Insights/Commerce and operations

When the gap between NMV and net sales passes 3%: fixing last mile and COD.

Cash on delivery still accounts for roughly 65 to 70% of monthly fashion e-commerce orders. Above a 3% gap between NMV and net sales, cash is leaking in delivery and collection.

Bespoke ResearchCommerce and operations4 min read

Why 3% is the red line

The gap measures cash that has not come back: goods have left the warehouse and marketing spend is booked. Every 1% of failed COD costs about 1.2% of EBITDA, and returns add storage costs and damaged stock.

The root causes

  • Carrier delivery times above 48 hours, so buyers change their minds.
  • No real-time tracking, so deliveries cannot be scheduled with customers.
  • High weekend storage charges in satellite cities.
  • Loose inspection and return rules that raise reverse-logistics costs.

The CURE playbook

  1. Consolidate 80% of volume with one or two top carriers for better rates and service levels.
  2. Underwrite inspection rights and return limits to lower damage risk.
  3. Route-plan with AI routing and automatic COD clustering to shorten delivery times.
  4. Engage customers with SMS and chatbot reminders two hours before delivery.

Add a COD surcharge for orders under VND 300,000 or to remote provinces, and move some customers to prepaid e-wallets with a cash-back incentive.

How to report it

  • Weekly COD success rate, before and after.
  • A Pareto chart of the provinces causing most failures.
  • A flow from order to delivery, failure and return.
  • Logistics cost by carrier.

Last mile is more than negotiating shipping rates. With data, clear service levels and shared risk, delivery success improves and margin comes back.

Notes

First published on bespokemarketing.asia and updated for this site. Figures are as cited in the original article; tool defaults are examples unless stated.